Elaborating more on this. Having slash, bludgeon,pierce to determine how hard u hit would be ok cause warriors would depend on str ruling the quality of the skill. Would be same for second attack since trolls got 71 71 so average is still 71. Third is the tricky one cause it also depends on dex and could be a bit more powerful, but since damage is down and a 35% penalty who knows, maybe not such a bit dif. First attack remains same and dual wield also has same deal as third and then could be implemented a penalty if its too good. Since right now dual wield is fine.
For rangers,thiefs would help on second attack since thats the one they use, it would increase a bit and dual would be ok since they use high dex and a good combo of str,con. Maybe would hit a bit harder but dunno how much. Depends on characters i guess and stats. And still the stats that rule the skills would have a deal in qualities so they wouldnt be increased.